03 September 2019

A Few Passing Thoughts on "God and the Faithfulness of Paul"

I ordered the 2017 volume God and the Faithfulness of Paul--the title of which is a little too cute as a response to N. T. Wright's 2013 magnum opus Paul and the Faithfulness of God--only so that I could read one essay, the one by Seyoon Kim critiquing Wright yet again on Wright's alleged anti-imperial polemic in Paul, which is relevant to a research project I'm working on. But I got sucked in as I began skimming a few of the other chapters. And reading Wright's response at the end of the book made me want to go see what the contributors had actually said. So I began reading the essays one by one.

What a fascinating book. The editors have done a good job bringing together a diverse collection of authors to engage with Wright. They deserve our thanks.

A few reflections, amid broad appreciation for this volume.

The Key Critique of Wright

It was striking to see a consistent refrain coming through from this very diverse group of contributors. The common thread of critique throughout the essays, amid much deep appreciation, was as follows:

Wright's brilliant and creative connecting of the dots, his shaping of the master-story of which Paul believed himself and his readers to be participants, refreshingly resists the staid categories within which the New Testament has been read for the past several generations (law/gospel, the objectivity of justification vs the subjectivity of the Spirit, covenant vs dispensational theology, etc) and rethinks Paul from the ground up; and yet the very creativity of Wright's schema of monotheism/election/eschatology, all reworked around Jesus as Messiah and the spirit (he doesn't like capitalizing the third Person of the Trinity), is itself at times imposed onto the text to fit neatly with Wright's broader reading of Paul.

In other words, his gift for seeing the forest makes one wonder if he is misreading some of the trees.

I find this critique accurate, time-tested, and confirming of my own reading of Wright over the years.

Why No Historical Theology?

One of the temptations and weaknesses of the New Testament guild is to neglect church history and historical theology. This is understandable; as Wright laments in his closing essay, one cannot possibly master even the contemporary literature on Paul, let alone what others over the centuries have said. Even to master the literature on a single Pauline letter is itself a full-time job--and of course, as soon as you feel on top of the secondary literature, a fresh wave of journal articles and monographs appears and the mastery instantly vanishes!

But it does not follow that just because one cannot cover all the contemporary perspective therefore one should say nothing about historical perspectives. In his 2009 justification book, Wright repeated aligned himself with Calvin as over against Luther. But the way he cast the two key reformers bent both of them out of shape, especially Luther. Why not have a chapter in the 2017 volume on Wright's reading of the reformers, or just of Calvin? Someone like Mike Allen or Mike Horton or Gerald Bray or Tony Lane could have provided a fascinating essay. The essay on a postmodern reading of Wright could easily have been dropped to make room for such a chapter.

Befitting the current academic climate, there's a chapter putting Wright in dialogue with Barth--but Wright doesn't engage with Barth in his books. He does engage with Calvin and others. And Barth's own historical hero was Calvin. Go to Calvin and see what he and the reformers would say of Wright's vision of Pauline theology. (This volume did just this.)

One way we can learn from Wright without letting him set all the terms in such discussions (putting us in danger of missing key questions that Paul probes but Wright doesn't) is to ask what thinkers 200 and 500 and 900 years ago were saying about Paul's letters.

As C. S. Lewis put it, there are two ways to get out of your own time and thus expose your generation's blind spots: (1) Get in a time machine and travel into the future and see what writers are saying about Paul; (2) Get in a time machine and travel into the past and do so. We can't do #1, but we can do #2, and we miss a great opportunity for fresh insight if we don't.

The Cappadocians and the Puritans and the Princeton School didn't have the Dead Sea Scrolls or SBL. But their insight into what Paul was saying often outstrips our own, sometimes in surprising, refreshing ways.

Why Ignore the Evangelicals?

Several of the contributors are pretty obscure, with some not even working in New Testament. In his closing response essay, Wright points this out more than once. While he appreciated the response from Gregory Sterling on the need to bolster Wright's reading of Paul through engagement with philosophy, Wright was rightly mystified by the essays of a few others who simply were not tracking with his argument (see Andrew McGowan's comments about Wright's use of "symbol" language as an example).

More broadly, I was surprised at how little evangelical scholarship was engaged, by which I mean the work of those who teach at confessional Protestant institutions and who take all 13 letters attributed to Paul as authentically Pauline. Some of the best Paul work is being done by evangelicals--Doug Moo, Greg Beale, Frank Thielman, Don Carson, Clint Arnold, Bob Yarbrough, and others. Tom Schreiner's contribution to Paul study was discussed in the opening essay, but that was about it.

Perhaps if Doug Moo's Pauline theology (in the big Zondervan series that Andreas Kostenberger is editing) had been available, Doug's work would have been more involved in the discussion--it would have been a fascinating exercise to put Moo and Wright in dialogue. But aside from the few pages putting Wright in interaction with Tom Schreiner, there is almost no interaction with evangelical scholarship. One reason that's striking to me is that Wright himself in more than one place has identified Doug Moo as among the most incisive of his critics--"a truly great Paul scholar" were Wright's words. So why not make him a major dialogue partner?

A Few of the More Interesting Chapters

Some of the essays were less useful, connected only glancingly with Wright's project. But a few are worth pointing out as particularly worth reading.

Benjamin Schliesser opened with an essay of impressive breadth as he placed Wright's Paul work among others. The discussion of Dunn vis-a-vis Wright was fascinating. As just mentioned, too bad there wasn't more engagement with evangelicals.

Seyoon Kim's essay built on John Barclay's strong critique of Wright's reading of Paul in which Rome looms large as a foil to Paul's gospel and the proclamation of Jesus (not Caesar) as Lord. Kim incisively shows why Wright's claim is overdone. It is not Rome and Caesar in themselves that are the threat to the church--it is Sin and Death and the Flesh that are the problems, problems which manifest themselves through Rome and in many other earthly constructs, but the problem is deeper than a particular imperial construct in itself.

Dunn's essay was a real chuckler. He's in the "scholars-who-have-nothing-left-to-prove-and-simply-say-what-they-think" bucket. Wright lamented in his closing essay Dunn's "schoolmasterish" tone, but I found Dunn's comments right on, with the exception of Dunn's continued skepticism toward the recent consensus building around an early high christology championed by Bauckham and Hurtado.

Sigurd Grindheim was masterful in treating Wright on election and showing that Israel's basic failure was not so much that they were not a light to the nations but, more deeply, that they did not trust and love the Lord above all.

The elderly Peter Stuhlmacher is always a joy to read, representing (with Martin Hengel) the best of German NT scholarship in my view, appreciating the New Perspective but retaining the deep and right anthropology that understands the perversity of fallen humanity and Paul's solution to it in the gospel as lying deeper than ethnic exclusivism and corporate inclusion, respectively.

Eckhard Schnabel's engagement with Wright's understanding of "mission" helps fill out and at points correct Wright's explications of conversion, evangelism, and the saving nature of the gospel. It is a firm, clear, and needed essay--though the objection to Wright calling Paul's travels "endless" and "restless," asserting that Paul's travels did come to an end and that surely Paul rested from time to time, was bizarre.

And then there's Wright's lengthy closing essay, filled with the usual elegant prose and gentlemanly appreciation of most of the essays, combined with annoyance at others caricaturing him (despite his own caricaturing of others) and, at times, magically melting away substantive disagreements with a wave of his monotheism-election-eschatology wand and Voila, all objections go poof!

In Closing . . .

Fascinating book. Interesting to see how others are understanding Wright, and good to keep benefiting from Wright himself, who is a gift to the church when read duly critically. But I hope collections of essays like this one don't reinforce the impression that NT scholarship doesn't need the insights of pre-Enlightenment readers of Paul.

And Doug, please get that Pauline theology in our hands quick as you can!

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

Deep stuff! Thank you for posting.

ankit said...

Undoubtedly it is the best explanation of the Indian education system. Moreover, education and Top private school in bhopal are also booming at a great pace. The number of best cbse school in kolar are also increasing as many parents wants to give the best education to their children. The beneficial curriculum of CBSE becomes famous which influenced a number of parents to enrol their children in the Best cbse school in Bhopal . Among them, all best school in ayodhy bypass bhopal are popular in Bhopal.

Debbie Wallace said...

HERBAL CURE FOR SHINGLES,WARTS AND HERPES,Hv/Aids 5 years ago I had warts, I was treated with some liquid applied to the warts they continued to grow and spread... The next 2 doctors did laser surgery to remove them. 1 year after the surgery, they grew back close to where the 1st ones were' so I was finally told it was SHINGLES. I have had it for a very long time, I contracted it from my cheated boyfriend and I found out he was also infected and I ended the relationship between us. The warts were so embarrassed because it started spreading all over. I have been dealing with these things for a very long time. The last treatment I took was About 2 years ago I applied for natural treatment from Dr. JAMES herbal cure, a week after applying the treatment all the warts were gone. It's now 2 years and some months I don't have a single wart or any symptoms of SHINGLES. wow"" it's great, Dr. JAMES has finally cured me. Anyone living with SHINGLES contact Dr. JAMES for natural treatments.his herbal medicine is easy to drink with no side effects. Dr.James has cure for diseases like Parkinson's disease,Schizophrenia,Lung Cancer,Breast Cancer,Colo-Rectal Cancer,Blood Cancer,Prostate Cancer ,Epilepsy Dupuytren's disease ,Coeliac disease,Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease,Cerebral Amyloid Angiopathy, Ataxia,Arthritis,Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis,Fibromyalgia,Fluoroquinolone Toxicity
Syndrome Fibrodysplasia Ossificans ProgresS sclerosis,Seizures,Alzheimer's disease,Adrenocortical carcinoma.Asthma,Allergic diseases ,Copd,Glaucoma., Cataracts,Macular degeneration,Cardiovascular disease,Lung disease.Enlarged prostate,Osteoporosis,Lupus,Cushing’s disease,Heart failure,Multiple Sclerosis,Hypertension,Lyme Disease,Blood Cancer,Brain Cancer,Breast Cancer,Lung Cancer,Kidney Cancer, HIV/AIDS, Herpes Virus,Hepatitis B, Liver Inflammatory,Diabetes,Fibroid. Contact Dr Jmaes who cured me on his Email  [drjamesherbalmix@gmail.com].  .

Katherine Flintoff said...

Lahore Smart City is going to be the best choice for commercial, investment and residential point of view. The scheme will have everything to attract national and international investors. In return, investors will get high revenue. On the other hand, the housing society is equipped with state of the art facilities. The facilities are just dream of come true for the people of Lahore. Peace, safety and eco-friendly behaviors Future Development Holding hires and corporate’s with world-class developers, architectures and planners. This Smart City Lahore will have golf clubs and fields designed by experienced and world-recognized designers.

Deal and Delas said...

After the success of residential and commercial plots, the developers of the RE housing society have introduced RE farmhouses with the secured gated community of Rudn Enclave Rawalpindi. Bringing not only the aesthetics but also the complete living experience of country houses well integrated with technology to offer a smart yet aesthetically appealing lifestyle to the residents.
park view lahore location
Rudn Enclave payment plan
Blue world city Islamabad map

Najaf Qureshi said...

I just visit your website and I found it very informative. Please share more content just like that. I want to read more content so please upload more articles. Thanks in advanced.

Packaging Host

Die Cut Stickers

Static Cling

Cheap Latest Products

Property Saga

Lahore Smart City

Nova City Islamabad

Park View City Islamabad

Al Noor Orchard Lahore

ahrealestatemarketing said...

This blog is very informative. Thanks for sharing such unique content. Please keep it up.
Best real estate company in Islamabad

Angela99 said...

I have enjoyed this article and also learn a beautiful topic that is mostly needed for me. Quran Academy Thanks for sharing an informational and helpful blog post. I really appreciate it.

Reviewer said...

Near the Twin Cities is an up-and-coming home development known as New City Paradise Islamabad, which will soon be made accessible to prospective investors.

Online Shiksha | Online Tuition Classes and Education Tips said...

First of all, I would like to thank you for sharing this great piece of content.
Do you know english is one of the most spoken languages in the world. But it is seen that many people face difficulties in speaking English fluently. This is because of a lack of confidence and fear of making their fun. If you are one of those people who hesitate to speak English then you may take online spoken english classes to improve your english speaking skills. Online english class will not only help you to speak english it will also help you to speak in public without any hesitation.

Anonymous said...

social media marketing company
search engine optimization uk
search engine optimization agency
seo company dubai
content writing
content writing services
content writing agency
website content writing services
logo design uae
brand logo design

nasrene pimental said...

nasrene pimental, we pride ourselves on presenting you with innovative and extraordinary app ideas that hold immense potential for growth and success. Our team of experts has meticulously crafted these ideas to ensure that they not only meet your requirements but also exceed them.

scott R Budde said...

Life-Changing Experience with Dr. Marcus Schmitz, Neurosurgeon Extraordinaire

Dear All,

I am writing to share my profound appreciation for Dr. Marcus Schmitz, a distinguished neurosurgeon who has been instrumental in curing my daughter's epileptic disease. For 13 long years, we battled this condition, but it was Dr. Schmitz's unique approach using natural remedies and treatments that finally brought us relief. 🙏

His expertise extends beyond epilepsy, encompassing other neurological diseases like Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, and stroke. I am confident that his innovative methods can bring hope and healing to others facing similar challenges. 🧠

I urge anyone dealing with these conditions to reach out to Dr. Schmitz directly. He can be contacted via email at dr.marcusschmitz@gmail.com or through WhatsApp at ‪+1 (973) 506‑8186‬. Time is of the essence in these matters, so please, do not hesitate. 🕰️

In Dr. Schmitz, you will find not just a doctor, but a dedicated ally in your fight against neurological diseases. Let's spread the word about this remarkable professional and help others find the relief they so desperately seek. 🌐

With utmost sincerity,

[scott Budde]

RealEstateLahore said...

Blue World City is a rapidly emerging residential project located in Islamabad, Pakistan. Touted as a collaborative venture between Chinese and Pakistani developers, the project aims to bring together modern infrastructure, urban planning, and architectural aesthetics to create a self-sustained and innovative community. With a distinct focus on providing affordable housing options, state-of-the-art amenities, and a blend of Chinese and Pakistani cultural elements, Blue World City envisions itself as a unique addition to the region's real estate landscape. The project's strategic location, just a short drive from Islamabad's main attractions and the new Islamabad International Airport, further enhances its appeal as a convenient and promising living destination.

Realtorspk said...

There are several online earning websites in Pakistan and platforms that people in Pakistan can utilize to make money from the comfort of their homes. These websites offer a variety of opportunities for earning, from freelance work to online businesses.